Tell me more ×
LEGO® Answers is a question and answer site for LEGO® and building block enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.
up vote 9 down vote favorite

For Lego's board game line, they have moulded a Lego die, with a 2x2 stud pattern on each side.

A picture of a Lego die; a standard 5-pip on one side, multicolored studless plates on another; and a third empty side are visible.

Obviously, weight distribution is going to be thrown off if you use a full studless plate on one side and four 1x1 studless plates on another because of the kerf.

Experimentally (by constructing different dice and rolling hundreds of times) or analytically (by analyzing the weight distribution of different plate configurations), how unfair can this die be assuming all studs are covered by a studless plate? What can be done to minimize the unfairness?

share|improve this question
2  
If you want to be torough, your assumption about all studs being covered has de be rescinded. Indeed, some of the games make heavy use of the "build your dice" feature, and add or remove tiles during the game itself. This adds a whole new dimension to the dice mechanics as event probabilities change over time, even if you ignore the unfairness introduced by the weight difference. Minimizing the unfairness can be of course by using only 2x2 tiles, but where's the fun in that? – Joubarc♦ Oct 29 '11 at 19:27
I don't think I've played a Lego game yet that allows empty die sides? Or perhaps I forgot - some of the games are fairly unmemorable. I'm also interested in any unfairness that may manifest for a plain die covered in 2x2 as well. – Joe Wreschnig Oct 29 '11 at 19:28
I don't expect much unfairness if all sides are covered by 2x2 tiles. From what? The paint? The LEGO dice is probably much more balanced than a regular Monopoly engraved dice. As for games where sides are built during the game, a lot of them do, and I think Lava Dragon is a good example: when you roll the dice, if there's room on the upper side, you may add a 1x1 tile of your color, then you can make as many moves as there are tiles of your color on that face (or something like that). – Joubarc♦ Oct 29 '11 at 19:51
Indeed, Lego's manufacturing genius has probably resulted in an extremely fair die - but like I said in the question, a good answer will be something empirical or analytic, and not assumed. (Lava Dragon is one I haven't played yet.) – Joe Wreschnig Oct 29 '11 at 19:54

1 Answer

up vote 8 down vote

conditions for unfairness:

  • different shaped tiles applied to each side resulting in different weight wich maked the dice "biased"

example:

the maximum difference in weight (when all studs get covered) is one side using a 2x2 tile and another side is using 4 1x1 tiles. the weight difference in this case is calculated based on using this measurements. to show the difference:

X X X X X X X X X X
X       . .       X
X       . .       X
X       . .       X
X . . . . . . . . X
X . . . . . . . . X
X       . .       X
X       . .       X
X       . .       X
X X X X X X X X X X

X = borders
. = border from the 1x1 tiles that are missing using a 2x2 tile

so there are ~ 28 legounits³ = 44.8 mm³ difference in material used. ABS, the material used for LEGo-bricks has a density of between 1.04 and 1.12 g/cm³ so 44.8 mm³ have a maximum height of:

1.12g/cm³ / 1000mm³ * 44.8mm³ = 0.050176g

0.05 g would be way too much for a precision-dice used in a casino, but for a "toy" it's almost nothing (it's less than 1% of the dices total weight - i'd like to calculate that, but i can't find information about it's weight), so i won't expect anyone to notice the LEGO-dice is "unfair".

EDIT:
found the dice on bricklink. weight: 8.02 g, so the 0.05 g are just ~ 0.6 % of the total weight.

share|improve this answer
3  
Actually, BrickLink will give you the weights for tiles too. A 2x2 is 0.48g and a 1x1 is 0.16g so the difference between one 2x2 and 4 1x1 is 0.16g. Which is not the highest unfairness you could have; as I said you can have empty sides, so the highest unfairness is empty side against 4 1x1 tiles, or a difference of 0.64g, or 8% of the total weight, which is bound to make a difference. Although usually when an empty side comes up you may add stuff on it so the situation is unlikely to happen. – Joubarc♦ Oct 30 '11 at 19:46
1  
i've chosen to compare 2x2 against 4 1x1 because that was one of the things asked ("a full studless plate on one side and four 1x1 studless plates on another"). the difference in this cas eas also much more interesting as the dice gets filled quickly and as long as there are empty sides its obvious the weight-difference is much higher. – oezi Oct 31 '11 at 6:35

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.